Skip to main content


The summer of 1977 was the summer of "Star Wars." It was everywhere, from Top-40 hits to tee-shirts to catchphrases. I saw the movie at the Clinton Theater in my hometown of Port Clinton, just after school let out in early June. Like many other impressionable youths who saw it, "Star Wars" had a profound impact on me and how I perceived science fiction. When I returned to school in the fall, one of the first things I did was ask my English teacher, Mrs. Dunham, if she could recommend any books like "Star Wars" for me to read. She told me I should check out a book called "Dune" by Frank Herbert. I went excitedly to our school library that same day, checked the book out, and immediately began reading. I got maybe 20 pages in, lost interest, and dropped it in the RETURN slot a few days later. Herbert used a style of writing called, "just throw a bunch of nonsensical words and phrases out there and get around to explaining them later," which I found less than compelling. The book also had an "Alibaba and the 40 Thieves" in space aesthetic that, even in those days before words like "jihad" had the connotations they do today, felt off to me.

Over the years, though, so many people have expressed their undying devotion to "Dune" that I wonder if I didn't miss out on something. I have some regret about not making a better effort to finish that first book, so I was intrigued when I saw that Dennis Villeneuve was trying his hand at a big-screen adaptation. 

Coming into the film with only the vaguest idea of the story allows me to evaluate it on its own merits, rather than some preconceived notion of what it "should" be, and I have to tell you that as a stand-alone experience, it's pretty good. Although "Dune" clocks in at almost two and a half hours, it never seemed to drag, and I was surprised that it was over so quickly. That may be partially due to the fact that it is just the first part of a two-part storyline, but it's a well-paced film that never seems to rush its material yet keeps the plot moving along. 

The general story is that 10,000 years into the future, the galaxy is divided into feudal "houses" ruled over by a galactic Emperor. Rule of the planet Arrakis, also known as Dune, is being transferred from House Harkonnen to House Atreides. Arrakis is the only known place in the galaxy where the spice, melange, is found. This spice is necessary for interstellar travel and may also help prolong life, so the House in charge of the mining operation there can earn fabulous wealth and live long enough to enjoy it. In theory. House Atreides may or may not know that they are being set up to fail by the Emperor, who fears they are becoming too powerful. 

Layered onto all this is a mysterious religious sect called Bene Gesserit that has interwoven itself with House Atreides. The sect believes in a prophecy that a male child born to one of its primarily female members will be the chosen one that can unlock the final mystery of their faith. Lady Atreides believes that her son, Paul, might be the chosen one and seeks validation from a Truthsayer who subjects Paul to a test. That test is actually how the book begins, and so it is one of the few things in the movie I recognized. 


While the question of Paul's exceptionalism is left ambiguous throughout the film, the mere fact that some believe he could be the chosen one has repercussions, and it is implied that he is not above using those beliefs to do good even if he doesn't exactly believe them, himself. That is a fascinating concept. 

The Emperor's agents work behind the scenes to make life on Arrakis difficult for House Atreides and then assist House Harkonnen outright in overthrowing and slaughtering them. Paul and his mother survive by fleeing to the desert where the indigenous people, known as the Fremen, eke out a subsistence in the murderous climate. Paul is able to best one of the Fremen warriors in a knife fight, furthering his case as a potential savior and earning a place for him and his mother in their clan. 

It's a compelling story, well-told, with outstanding visuals. Villeneuve wisely tones down the Middle Eastern aspects of the original story, which was pretty obviously a critique of colonial oil interests in that part of the world at the time the book was published in 1965, in favor of a more generic colonial setting. 

The first couple chapters of the book clarify why the galaxy lacks computers and robots, an anti-tech uprising known as the Butlerian Jihad, but the film is oddly vague about that, which is somewhat weird because it is ultimately what makes spice so valuable. The superhuman ability to concentrate and process information it provides allows humans to do the calculations needed to navigate interstellar space. I'm sure that somewhere in the 12 Dune books, there is an explanation of how the spice on that distant planet was originally found if spice was needed to travel there in the first place, but for now, I'll call it a conundrum and move on.  

The thing that most stands out to me about "Dune" is just how derivative "Star Wars" is of it. Desert planet. Chosen one. Evil Emperor. Mysterious religious sect with mind-bending powers. Swordplay. In retrospect, it's easy to see why Mrs. Dunham thought "Dune" would be a logical progression from "Star Wars."


I was originally a Radio/Television Communication major at Ohio University before switching to Business Administration. One of the core RTVC classes was "Interpretation of Film," which I took Fall Quarter of my sophomore year. It remains my favorite class of all time. Every Friday at 2:00, we would gather in the theater at Baker Center and watch a classic movie, then discuss it on Monday and Wednesday of the next week. A few of us from the class would go out for a beer or two before the screening and that became known as our "Friday Matinee." Fittingly, I award movies mugs of beer as follows:

🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺 -  A modern classic. Entertaining, with no significant flaws.

🍺🍺🍺🍺 - A great viewing experience, with just a few minor issues.

🍺🍺🍺 - Well worth watching, but some significant quibbles.

🍺🍺 - Watchable, but not worth your time unless a fan of the director, actors, or source material.

🍺- Save your money.



Popular posts from this blog

Don't Listen to the Old Man in the Pickup Truck

As economic development director for Anson County, I strongly urge you to vote FOR the Mixed Beverage* Election November 8th. But, more importantly, I encourage you to listen to the voices of the young professionals upon whom the future of the county will depend. If you look closely at the lower right-hand corner of the blue and white signs urging a FOR vote on Mixed Beverages, you will see they are paid for by YP Anson. So what is YP Anson? Is it some political action committee funded by out-of-state alcoholic beverage manufacturers and casino owners? No, it's Young Professionals Anson, an organization made up of and funded entirely by local business people and community members under the age of 40.  They are the bankers, real estate agents, lawyers, shop owners, entrepreneurs, factory managers, and tradespeople who will lead Anson County into the next decade and beyond. Most of them were born and raised here, left to get a college education, and chose to return and raise a family


Ford Motor Company recently announced they are suspending orders for their Maverick (A) compact truck because they have outsold the company's capacity to manufacture them. The Maverick is an anomaly in today's pickup truck market, where bigger is better, and even bigger is even better. My "midsize" Toyota Tacoma is as large as many full-size pickups from the early 2000s. A new full-size F-150 or Silverado wouldn't have looked out of place at a monster truck show in the '70s.  The major truck manufacturers justify their increasingly enormous vehicles by claiming "no market" for smaller trucks. The success of the Maverick, however, would seem to contradict that.  The Maverick is based on the Ford Escape compact SUV, and while it is slightly longer than the Escape, it is significantly smaller than any other pickup currently sold in the U.S. It does not have the towing capacity or off-road capabilities of larger trucks, but it should work just fine for t

FIELD NOTES: Solar Is Everywhere and Nowhere

I received a Science Fair 20-in-1 Electronics Project kit for Christmas one year in my early teens. It consisted of 15 "blocks," each with a component like a transistor or a diode that could be wired together to create projects like an oscilloscope, rain alarm, or diode radio. One of the blocks was a solar cell about the size of a postage stamp. It produced very little power, even in direct sunlight, but it did demonstrate that electricity could be generated directly from the sun, a technology that was getting a lot of publicity in the early '70s. The mass market "technical" magazines of the day, Popular Mechanics and Popular Science, featured articles about the exciting future of solar energy while acknowledging several hurdles to overcome before it ever became a mainstream power source. Those publications were sure, however, that advances in photovoltaic (PV) cells and electric storage would make solar energy ubiquitous by the turn of the century. In some ways